Category: Social Issues

Divorce is never easy. It is the painful unraveling of a relationship that once promised love, companionship, and a future together. Yet, in recent years, India has witnessed a disturbing rise in divorces fueled not just by broken relationships, but by battles over alimony — the financial support one spouse demands from the other after separation. What was once a mechanism to support a struggling partner has, in many cases, turned into a weapon of prolonged legal and emotional warfare. The Emotional Toll Behind the Legal Battles Behind every divorce, there’s a deeply emotional story of broken dreams, trust shattered, and families torn apart. When alimony becomes the center of the conflict, it often extends the pain far beyond the separation. Instead of healing and moving forward, couples are entangled in bitter disputes over money, sometimes dragging on for years. These conflicts drain emotional energy and sometimes deepen the wounds caused by the breakup. It is important to remember that alimony was originally intended as a safety net to ensure that the spouse who might be financially weaker is not left destitute. However, as the number of such cases rises, so does public debate about misuse and manipulation of the law for personal gain. High-Profile Cases Shining a Spotlight Two recent cases have sparked national conversations and stirred public emotions: the Yuzvendra Dhanshree divorce alimony case and the Atul Subhash alimony case. Both highlight the complexities and controversies surrounding alimony battles in modern India. Yuzvendra Dhanshree Divorce Alimony Case Yuzvendra Dhanshree, a prominent businessman from Mumbai, filed for divorce after 10 years of marriage. The split was amicable, but tensions quickly escalated when his wife demanded a staggering monthly alimony of ₹5 lakhs (500,000 INR). Dhanshree claimed this amount was unreasonable, especially since his wife had a thriving boutique business earning a steady income of approximately ₹3 lakhs per month. This case caught public attention not just because of the sums involved, but also due to the emotional testimonies on both sides. Yuzvendra spoke of his efforts to support the family during their marriage and felt betrayed by the escalating financial demands. Meanwhile, his wife expressed concern about losing financial security, especially as she was still adjusting to a new life without the stability of marriage. The ongoing court battles have delayed the closure both parties desperately need, showing how alimony disputes can prolong the pain of separation. Atul Subhash Alimony Case Another striking case is Atul Subhash, a middle-class software engineer from Pune. Atul’s divorce and alimony dispute became a media talking point because it revealed how even ordinary people are caught in this spiraling conflict. Atul’s ex-wife demanded a lump sum alimony of ₹30 lakhs (3 million INR), arguing that she sacrificed her career for the family’s welfare. Atul, on the other hand, argued that while he respected her sacrifices, the demands were unrealistic given his salary of ₹80,000 per month and obligations to their children. This case illustrated the emotional struggle of many men and women caught between societal expectations, financial realities, and legal battles. For Atul, the fight was not just about money — it was about dignity, fairness, and the hope for a peaceful future. Why Are Alimony Battles Increasing? Several factors contribute to this trend: Changing Social Norms: As more women become financially independent, traditional expectations of marriage and support are evolving. However, many still expect alimony to maintain a certain lifestyle post-divorce, which sometimes leads to disputes. Legal Awareness: Increased awareness about legal rights means more people are demanding what they believe is fair, leading to more litigation. Economic Pressures: The rising cost of living and financial uncertainties put additional strain on separated couples, making alimony negotiations more contentious. Misuse of Laws: Unfortunately, some cases reveal the exploitation of alimony laws, with demands made more as a strategy to hurt the other spouse rather than out of genuine need. The Human Cost Behind every case is a human story. Divorces fought over alimony are often a tragic reminder that financial security is tied deeply to emotional well-being. Many spouses, both men and women, suffer in silence, facing humiliation, financial hardship, and mental stress. The children, too, are innocent bystanders in these battles. They often witness their parents’ pain and legal struggles, which can affect their emotional development and sense of security. When Should Alimony Be Demanded? The rise in alimony battles raises an important question: If a partner is financially independent and earning well, should there be a demand for alimony? Here are some suggestions based on social and legal perspectives: Assess Financial Dependency Fairly: Alimony’s original purpose is to support the financially weaker spouse. If the partner requesting alimony has a stable income that covers their living expenses comfortably, demanding large alimony may not be justified. Lifestyle Considerations: Courts often consider the lifestyle the couple enjoyed during marriage. If both partners have independent incomes, the need for alimony should reflect a fair adjustment rather than an attempt to maintain a lavish lifestyle at the other’s expense. Focus on Children’s Welfare: If children are involved, alimony or child support should prioritize their needs and well-being above all else. Encourage Amicable Settlements: Financial disputes are less painful when partners agree on fair terms outside court. Mediation and counseling can help in such negotiations. Legal Reform and Clear Guidelines: There is a growing demand for clearer legal frameworks that define alimony based on income, financial needs, and the partner’s ability to support themselves, to avoid prolonged and expensive court battles. The Human CostBehind every case is a human story. Divorces fought over alimony are often a tragic reminder that financial security is tied deeply to emotional well-being. Many spouses, both men and women, suffer in silence, facing humiliation, financial hardship, and mental stress.The children, too, are innocent bystanders in these battles. They often witness their parents’ pain and legal struggles, which can affect their emotional development and sense of security. Finding a Way Forward The rise in divorces for alimony battles calls for a